2018 split
Mexican Duck vs. Mallard: a species of its own since 2018
The Mexican Duck is not a Mallard but a species of its own again: eBird and its Clements Checklist split it from the Mallard in August 2018, and the American Ornithological Society (AOS) followed on June 30, 2020. It lives in the Southwest and Mexico, and the surest clue is the tail, brown on a Mexican Duck and mostly white on a Mallard. If you have seen both a Mallard and a Mexican Duck, your list goes up by one.
Updated
What changed
Across most of North America, Europe and Asia, including the Southwest, where it meets Mexican Duck.
Nests from southeastern Arizona, southern New Mexico and west Texas south into the highlands of central Mexico. A few wander north to Colorado and Utah.
Mexican Duck vs. Mallard: what is the difference?
Look at the tail. On every Mexican Duck, male or female, the tail and the feathers under it are largely brown; on a Mallard the tail is mostly white, writes Jack Bushong for the American Birding Association (ABA). That helps most in summer, when male Mallards can look like Mexican Ducks.
Both sexes of the Mexican Duck look like a female Mallard, only darker. The male has a bright yellow bill, the female a dull olive to orange one, says Audubon's field guide. The white borders of the blue wing patch are thin on a pure Mexican Duck and noticeably thicker on a Mallard.
Mallard genes show. A male with green on the head, rust on the breast or curled central tail feathers has Mallard ancestry, writes Michael Retter of the ABA. But young male Mexican Ducks can show a little green and curled feathers too, Ducks Unlimited warns; adults don't.
What is a Mexican Duck called?
Mexican Duck, Anas diazi: that is its official name with the AOS, eBird and AviList, the shared world checklist. Robert Ridgway described it in 1886, from Puebla, in central Mexico, says AviList.
Older names live on. Big Bend National Park's birding page still sends visitors to the Rio Grande to look for the “Mexican mallard.” In Mexico it is the pato mexicano or pato garbancero, says a 2019 study in the University of Guanajuato's journal. And in 1920 the naturalist Wharton Huber described the birds of the Rio Grande as a new species, the “New Mexican Duck,” in The Auk.
Surprising facts about the Mexican Duck
It was on the first US endangered species list. The Mexican Duck was named in the government's list of endangered native wildlife of March 11, 1967. In 1978 the US Fish and Wildlife Service took it off, writing that the original reasons for listing it “are now known to have been incorrect.” It judged the US birds to be hybrids.
The government gave a pure one 1-in-10,000 odds. In that 1978 rule the Service put the chance that any genetically pure Mexican Ducks were left in the US at “perhaps 1 in 10,000 or 100,000.” Later DNA work found only about 2 percent hybrids, a 2015 study reported, as the AOS proposal notes.
A breeding program backfired. In the 1960s New Mexico's game department tried to raise and release pure Mexican Ducks. It gave up when the young showed obvious hybrid features, the 1978 rule says.
In Mexico, flocks can blacken the sky. “I can show you a place in Chihuahua where there's Mexican ducks that will blacken the sky,” the waterfowl geneticist Philip Lavretsky of the University of Texas at El Paso told Ducks Unlimited in 2023.
Why it changed
Mostly DNA. A 2019 study by Philip Lavretsky and colleagues compared some 3,200 places in the genomes of North America's Mallard-like ducks and found no Mexican Duck with signs of recent mixing, says the AOS proposal that settled it. The genes showed “that gene flow between them is limited, which was enough to convince the committee,” its chair, Terry Chesser, said in 2020.
It took three tries. A proposal to restore the species failed in 2010; a second, by Tom Schulenberg of the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, failed in 2018 by three votes to seven; the third, written by Irby Lovette and Shawn Billerman with the new genetic results, passed.
It had been a species before. The 1957 Check-list of North American birds listed the Mexican Duck as one. The 1983 edition merged it with the Mallard, saying extensive hybridization in southeastern Arizona, southern New Mexico and west Texas “compels merger.”
Who decided, and when
- eBird and the Clements Checklist: its 2018 taxonomy update
- American Ornithological Society (AOS): the 61st Supplement to its Check-list, two years after its committee had turned the split down
- AviList, the shared world checklist: agrees, with the same names
What duck looks like a mallard but isn't?
Several. The ABA counts five species in the Mallard group in the US and Canada: the Mallard, American Black Duck, Mottled Duck, Hawaiian Duck and Mexican Duck. Audubon's field guide tells you to compare a female Mallard with the Mottled Duck in Florida and on the Gulf Coast, and with the Mexican Duck in the Southwest.
An American Black Duck is very dark, almost blackish, and a pure one has no white edging on its wing patch. A Mottled Duck has no white borders there either, and warmer, peachy cheeks. A female Gadwall is mottled brown too, but has a steeper forehead and a square white patch on the trailing edge of the wing.
Are Mexican Ducks rare?
In the US, yes; in Mexico, no. Ducks Unlimited cites estimates of about 55,000 birds, 98 percent of them in Mexico and only about 1,100 in Arizona, New Mexico and Texas. Audubon's field guide puts the total under 80,000.
Most live in the highlands of central Mexico, with the biggest numbers where Guanajuato, Michoacán and Jalisco meet, the Guanajuato study says. In 2023 the US Fish and Wildlife Service added it by name to the list of birds protected by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act.
Where can Mexican Ducks be found in Texas?
In the Trans-Pecos, the far west of the state. Texas's breeding bird atlas calls them rare to locally common residents there; nearly all the nesting places its volunteers found from 1987 to 1992 were in that region. At Big Bend National Park, try the Rio Grande near the Daniels Ranch picnic area.
They are found regularly as far east as McAllen, and wanderers have reached South Padre Island, writes Retter. Along the lower Rio Grande, watch for hybrids with the Mottled Duck. The river between Laredo and Falcon Dam is also home to another 2018 split: Morelet's Seedeater, until then the White-collared Seedeater.
Can you hunt Mexican Ducks?
Yes, within each state's limits. In Texas it counts as a “dusky” duck, with the Mottled and American Black Ducks and their hybrids, and in El Paso County the 2026–27 limit is one dusky duck a day, says Texas Parks and Wildlife. In New Mexico's Central Flyway zones it counts toward the mallard limit. Harvest in the US is believed to be very low, says Ducks Unlimited.
Where can you see a Mexican Duck?
In southeast Arizona, southern New Mexico and west Texas, and south through the highlands of Mexico, according to AviList. It is common north to Albuquerque and west to Yuma, Arizona, and strays have reached Utah, Wyoming and Nebraska, writes Retter.
At Sweetwater Wetlands Park in Tucson it may outnumber the Mallard in winter, says the ABA. The purest-looking birds in Arizona are more often found south and east of Tucson, for example along the San Pedro River east of Sierra Vista, wrote David Sibley.
Which one did you see?
Go by place first. Away from the Southwest and Mexico, a Mallard-type duck is almost always a Mallard.
In the Southwest, check the tail: brown on a Mexican Duck, mostly white on a Mallard. More clues are above.
The two often interbreed where they meet. When a bird is hard to call, the ABA suggests reporting it as “Mallard/Mexican Duck.”
What it does to your list
If you have seen both a Mallard and a Mexican Duck, your total goes up by one. Birders call a species gained from a split, without a new sighting, an “armchair lifer.”
If you logged a “Mallard (Mexican)” in eBird before August 2018, it is now a Mexican Duck: the Clements Checklist raised that form to a species. If you have only seen Mallards, nothing changes.
The AOS announced it together with another change: “Goodbye Northwestern Crow, Hello Mexican Duck.” See the Northwestern Crow lump.
Logged a “Mallard (Mexican)” before 2018? It should now read Mexican Duck: get a fresh copy of your eBird data and look for it.
Check your own list. Drop your eBird download or type your birds: the free checker shows which of them this and other recent changes touched.
Check my list