2018 split

White-collared Seedeater split: the Texas bird is Morelet's Seedeater

White-collared Seedeater is now two species: the American Ornithological Society (AOS) split it in June 2018, and eBird followed in August 2018. The little seedeater of the Rio Grande in south Texas is now Morelet's Seedeater; the Cinnamon-rumped Seedeater lives in western Mexico. For US birders it's a new name, not a new bird.

Updated

What changed

WasWhite-collared Seedeater Sporophila torqueola
NowMorelet's Seedeater Sporophila morelleti

The seedeater of the US: along the Rio Grande in south Texas, and south along the Gulf and Caribbean side of Mexico and Central America to western Panama.

NowCinnamon-rumped Seedeater Sporophila torqueola

Western and interior Mexico, from southern Sonora south to Oaxaca, and the south of Baja California. There are a few reports from the US, but none has been accepted.

Is White-collared Seedeater now Morelet's Seedeater?

In Texas, yes: the White-collared Seedeater of the Rio Grande is now Morelet's Seedeater, Sporophila morelleti. The AOS split White-collared Seedeater in two in June 2018, eBird followed in August 2018, and AviList, the shared world checklist, agrees.

The old name lives on in places. BirdLife International's world list still calls this bird White-collared Seedeater, AviList's comparison of the lists shows, and so does the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department's guide to its birding trails.

Surprising facts about Morelet's Seedeater

It is the only true tanager that nests in the US. Seedeaters belong to the tanager family; the Summer, Scarlet and Western Tanagers are, despite their names, in the cardinal family, the AOS Check-list shows. That makes Morelet's “the only species of tanager which regularly breeds in the continental United States,” wrote Michael Retter of the American Birding Association (ABA).

Its name is a typo that stuck. It honors Pierre Marie Arthur Morelet (1809–1892), a French naturalist who collected the first specimens near Petén, Guatemala, in 1847. The scientific name misspelled him as morelleti, and under the naming rules the misspelling stands. His name was already on a crocodile and a tree frog, but on no bird's English name, Chesser noted.

It nearly vanished from Texas. In 1949, two Christmas Bird Counts in the Rio Grande delta tallied 107 seedeaters. From 1965 on, with six counts running, only a single one had been recorded by the time the Texas Breeding Bird Atlas updated its account in 2007.

Its nests can include horsehair and rags. Texas nests have been made of fine rootlets, cobwebs, palm fiber, moss and grass, with strips of cloth and horsehair, 2 to 4 feet up in a willow, a shrub or a giant ragweed, the atlas says.

Why it changed

Museum skins and genes. In 2018, Nicholas Mason and colleagues compared 663 specimens and the DNA of 68 birds. The cinnamon-rumped birds of western Mexico and the white-collared birds of the Gulf side formed separate groups that could be told apart about 90 percent of the time, with little or no gene flow between them, Mason's proposal to the AOS reports.

They may not even be each other's closest relatives: in their mitochondrial DNA, the western birds sat nearer other seedeaters, such as the Variable Seedeater, than to the eastern ones. Their songs differ too: the eastern birds' songs often end in a rapid, buzzy trill that the western birds' shorter songs lack.

The new name is an old one. Rather than keep White-collared Seedeater for one half, the AOS brought back Morellet's Seedeater, the name in its first Check-list in 1886, with the spelling corrected. The Texas bird had been Sharpe's Seedeater in the editions of 1895 to 1931, noted Terry Chesser, who chairs the AOS committee.

Who decided, and when

  • American Ornithological Society (AOS): the 59th Supplement to its Check-list of North American birds
  • eBird and the Clements Checklist: its 2018 taxonomy update
  • AviList, the shared world checklist: agrees, with the same names

Where can you see Morelet's Seedeater in Texas?

Along the Rio Grande between Laredo and Falcon Dam, south of Zapata, says Texas Parks & Wildlife magazine. It lives there all year but is easiest to find in early spring, in reedy, grassy spots by the river and weedy fields nearby.

Try the weedy field by the public library and the cattail pond in Zapata's city park, and the Seedeater Sanctuary in San Ygnacio, a Zapata County park on the river flood plain at the end of Washington Avenue, where the birds nest in the cane, says the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department. In Laredo, the magazine suggests La Casa Blanca International State Park, La Laja Ranch and the Laredo Community College campus. Seedeaters also turn up upriver at Del Rio and downriver at Salineño Wildlife Preserve, says the website Birdfinding.info.

How rare is Morelet's Seedeater in the US?

Rare, and found only in a small part of south Texas. It once ranged from Laredo to Brownsville and up the coast to Corpus Christi, but has declined steeply since 1946, says the Texas Breeding Bird Atlas; in 1995 and 1996, observers found only 7 to 9 pairs in Zapata County.

It was common in extreme south Texas as recently as the 1940s and had all but vanished by the mid-1970s, before it reappeared in small numbers around Falcon Dam, says Audubon's field guide. Why it declined is poorly understood. Farther south it is still widespread and common, and may have increased where forest was cleared; the IUCN lists it as Least Concern, AviList shows.

How do you identify a Morelet's Seedeater?

By its size and bill: it's tiny, about 4 inches long, with a very short, stubby bill, says Audubon's field guide. The male has a blackish cap, a partial pale collar, and a white wing spot and wing bars; the female and young are plain buff with fainter wing bars.

Texas males are paler than most: northern birds tend to show a washed-out gray-and-buff version of the black-and-white pattern, usually without a clear black band across the chest, says Birdfinding.info. Flocks feed low in weedy places, calling softly, and the male's song is a surprisingly clear whistle, Audubon's guide says.

Which one did you see?

Go by where you saw it. In Texas, and on the Gulf and Caribbean side of Mexico and Central America, it's Morelet's Seedeater. In western and interior Mexico, it's Cinnamon-rumped Seedeater.

Cinnamon-rumped Seedeater has been reported from Nogales, Arizona, Mission, Texas, and San Diego, where at least four were seen at once near the Tijuana River mouth, but none of these records has been accepted. It's a pretty songbird that does well in cages, so caution is warranted, Retter wrote.

What it does to your list

For US birders it's a new name only: the White-collared Seedeater you saw in Texas is now Morelet's Seedeater.

If you have also seen Cinnamon-rumped Seedeater in western Mexico, your total goes up by one, an “armchair lifer.” For birders who knew both, the split was long overdue: Steve Howell had already treated them as two species in his bird-finding guide to Mexico of 1998, Retter noted.

Another change that year: the Gray Jay, now Canada Jay. And read more about how bird splits and lumps work.

Seen Morelet's Seedeater along the Rio Grande? Turn your list into a book, each bird with the day and place you first found it.

Check your own list. Drop your eBird download or type your birds: the free checker shows which of them this and other recent changes touched.

Check my list