2021 split

Mew Gull split: ours is Short-billed Gull

Mew Gull is now two species: the American Ornithological Society (AOS) split it on June 29, 2021, and eBird followed in August 2021. The Mew Gull of western North America is now the Short-billed Gull, the name it had in the first Check-list of North American birds, in 1886; the Common Gull is the bird of Europe and Asia. For most birders in the US and Canada it's a new name, not a new bird.

Updated

What changed

WasMew Gull Larus canus
NowShort-billed Gull Larus brachyrhynchus

Nests in Alaska and northwestern Canada. Winters along the Pacific coast, from British Columbia to northern Baja California.

NowCommon Gull Larus canus

Nests across northern Europe and Asia. In North America only an occasional visitor, to Alaska and the East.

What is a Mew Gull called now?

In North America, Short-billed Gull. The AOS split Mew Gull in two on June 29, 2021: the North American bird became the Short-billed Gull, Larus brachyrhynchus, and the bird of Europe and Asia the Common Gull, Larus canus. eBird followed in its August 2021 update.

For most birders, as David Sibley put it, this simply means changing the name on your list from Mew Gull to Short-billed Gull.

Why is it called Short-billed Gull?

Because that was its name before. Short-billed Gull was the name in the very first Check-list of North American birds, in 1886, the AOS notes, and it is apt: the small bill is one of the bird's most obvious field marks, the proposal says. Mew Gull came in only in 1957, as the name of the combined species, a committee member found.

“Mew” isn't the bird's call. It comes from old Anglo-Saxon and Middle English words for a gull, so Mew Gull means, in effect, “Gull Gull,” one committee member pointed out in 2022, when a proposal to bring back the name Mew Gull failed.

Surprising facts about the Short-billed Gull

It nests in trees. It is the only white-headed gull that regularly does, says Birds of the World, sometimes on a stump or in dense spruce up to 20 feet up, adds Audubon's field guide. In Anchorage, a study from 1979 to 1982 found nests on vehicles, pipeline supports and buildings.

It's an inland gull too. It is the most common gull in interior Alaska, far from the coast, says the Alaska Songbird Institute in Fairbanks.

It bombs its shellfish. It sometimes carries hard-shelled mollusks into the air and drops them on rocks to break them open, says Audubon's field guide.

A Russian cousin keeps coming back to Massachusetts. The Kamchatka form of the Common Gull has turned up in the eastern US in 19 of the 20 years from 2006 to 2025, yet it was first found on the West Coast south of Alaska only on December 29, 2024, Massachusetts' bird records committee reports. One, nicknamed Old Reliable, has 18 years of records on the state's North Shore.

The Common Gull isn't common. Despite its name, it is not particularly common in Britain, and is even on the country's Red List of birds of conservation concern, says the RSPB.

Why it changed

Mostly their calls. The split rests mainly on differences in display calls, with genetic and other differences besides, set out in a proposal by Pamela Rasmussen of Michigan State University, a member of the AOS committee, the AOS said. AviList cites the same calls and a gap in their mitochondrial DNA, with no sign of interbreeding.

The two had been lumped on what the AOS now calls weak evidence, a paper of 1919. The Check-list kept the American bird as a species of its own through its third edition and merged it with the Old World one in its fourth, in 1931, the proposal notes.

Who decided, and when

  • American Ornithological Society (AOS): the 62nd Supplement to its Check-list of North American birds
  • eBird and the Clements Checklist: its 2021 taxonomy update
  • AviList, the shared world checklist: agrees, with the same names

How do you tell a Short-billed Gull from a Common Gull?

With difficulty. On an adult's wingtip, the black forms a fairly even, forked V in the Short-billed Gull and a more solid black triangle in the Common Gull, writes David Sibley. In winter the Short-billed usually has a drab greenish bill with at most a faint dusky ring; the Common often shows a more distinct blackish ring.

Many key marks show only on a fully spread wing, so even experts need sharp photos, Sibley says. Place helps most: on the Pacific coast it's a Short-billed; in Newfoundland, Common Gull is the expected one, and Short-billed has never been recorded there.

What is the red thing on a seagull's beak?

A red spot near the tip of the bill of many big gulls, such as the American Herring Gull. Chicks peck at it to get fed, and the scientist Niko Tinbergen showed it was a crucial signal for their survival, work that helped earn him a Nobel Prize in 1973, says BirdNote. More in the Herring Gull split.

The Short-billed Gull has no such spot: an adult's bill is thin and unmarked yellow, says Audubon's field guide.

Are a gull and a seagull the same thing?

Yes: seagull is the everyday word for any gull, not one species. “There's no such thing as a seagull,” the RSPB says, counting around 50 species of gull worldwide. Many live far from the sea, like the Short-billed Gulls of interior Alaska.

What is the smallest gull species?

The Little Gull, which Audubon's field guide calls the smallest of the gulls. It came to North America from Europe and was first found nesting here in 1962. Among North America's white-headed gulls, the smallest is the Short-billed Gull, says Birds of the World.

What is the rarest gull in the world?

Probably the Lava Gull, found only in the Galápagos Islands, with a total population of 300 to 600 birds, says the Galapagos Conservation Trust.

Do baby seagulls return to the same nest?

Not to the same nest, but often to the same colony, the males more than the females. In a long study of Common Gulls in Estonia, 41 percent of males but only 4 percent of females nested in the colony where they had hatched. The adults were faithful: only 5 percent of pairs changed nesting islands from one season to the next, and the pair bond was usually for life.

Where can you see a Short-billed Gull?

On the Pacific coast in winter, from southern British Columbia to northern Baja California, according to AviList. It is one of the most abundant wintering gulls there, often foraging with Ring-billed Gulls in coastal farm fields, says the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife.

Fall migration is late, and many don't reach their winter homes until November. In summer it nests in Alaska and northwestern Canada, where it is often seen perched on top of spruce trees, says Audubon's field guide. In the East it is extremely rare: Massachusetts has four records, all adults, from 2015 to 2019, its records committee says.

Which one did you see?

Go by where you saw it. On the Pacific coast, and in Alaska and western Canada, it's Short-billed Gull.

Common Gull is a rare visitor here: European birds reach Newfoundland and the Northeast, and the Kamchatka form strays to western Alaska.

The everyday look-alike is the Ring-billed Gull, 17 to 21 inches long, with pale eyes and a neat black ring on its yellow bill. The Short-billed, 16 to 18 inches, has a dark eye, a thin unmarked yellow bill, a darker gray back and a round head that gives it a “gentle” look, says Audubon's field guide.

What it does to your list

For most birders in the US and Canada it's a new name only: your Mew Gull is now Short-billed Gull.

If you have also seen Common Gull, in Europe or Asia or as a rare visitor here, your total goes up by one. “If you're a coast-to-coast birder, you may be able to pick up a new species this winter,” the AOS committee's chair, Terry Chesser, said in 2021.

Two years earlier the AOS split a sea duck the same way, from its relatives in Europe and Asia: see the White-winged Scoter split.

To keep a copy of your whole list, gulls and all, here's how to download your eBird data as a file you can open as a spreadsheet.

Check your own list. Drop your eBird download or type your birds: the free checker shows which of them this and other recent changes touched.

Check my list