2024 split
Cory's Shearwater split: Cory's and Scopoli's
Cory's Shearwater is now two species: the American Ornithological Society (AOS) split it on July 18, 2024, and eBird followed in October 2024. The Atlantic bird keeps the name Cory's Shearwater, and the Mediterranean one is now Scopoli's Shearwater. Both are seen at sea off the US East Coast, so if you have seen both, and your records say which, your list goes up by one.
Updated
What changed
Nests on islands in the eastern Atlantic, from the Azores to the Canaries, and off Spain and Portugal. The more common of the two off eastern North America.
Nests on islands in the Mediterranean. Seen less often off eastern North America, most in late summer.
What are the key differences between Cory's Shearwater and Scopoli's Shearwater?
Mainly the underside of the wing. On Scopoli's, the white of the underwing reaches farther out toward the tip, so the bases of the long outer wing feathers look pale, often with a white "tongue" on the outermost; on Cory's they are dark, say Retter and the Carolina Bird Club. Scopoli's is also slightly lighter in build, with a thinner bill.
It takes a good look. A 2021 study of museum specimens and photos by Robert Flood and Ricard Gutiérrez found that most birds can be told apart in the field, but that some overlap. In North Carolina, photos may be needed to confirm a Scopoli's.
Their homes differ too. Cory's nests on Atlantic islands from the Azores to the Canaries; Scopoli's nests on Mediterranean islands and in southwestern France, says AviList.
Surprising facts about Cory's and Scopoli's Shearwaters
They find their way home by smell. Researchers took Cory's Shearwaters from the Azores and released them 800 kilometers (500 miles) out in the Atlantic. Birds carrying magnets flew home along straight routes, but birds whose sense of smell had been blocked wandered for thousands of kilometers. A 2017 tracking study of Scopoli's Shearwaters from the Balearic Islands found the same: without smell, they lost their bearing over open sea.
Cory's was named from a bird off Massachusetts. Charles B. Cory described the species in 1881 from a bird taken off Chatham Island, Massachusetts, according to AviList. Scopoli's honors the naturalist Giovanni Antonio Scopoli, who described the Mediterranean bird in 1769; say it SKOH-poh-lee, says Retter.
Streetlights are a trap for the young. About 75 percent of the world's Cory's Shearwaters nest in the Azores. Each October the young leave their burrows for the sea, are dazzled by artificial lights and fall, often onto roads. Since 1995 the islands' SOS Cory's Shearwater campaign has rescued more than 85,000, releasing them the next morning.
Thousands can pass Cape Hatteras in a day. Counters on shore at Cape Hatteras Point tallied 8,850 on October 28, 1974, and 6,127 on June 7, 2022, says the Carolina Bird Club. Hurricanes have even blown a few inland, to Lake Waccamaw and the Neuse River at New Bern.
Why it changed
Experts had suspected it for years. In 2012 George Sangster and colleagues, writing in the journal Ibis, recommended treating Cory's, Scopoli's and Cape Verde Shearwaters as three species, ACAP reported. The evidence: separate groups in the birds' DNA, differences in size and in the white under the wing, and different voices. In playback tests, the birds even responded differently to recordings of each kind.
They rarely interbreed, even where they meet. Both nest on the Chafarinas Islands, off the Mediterranean coast of Morocco, with limited hybridization, notes Michael Retter of the American Birding Association (ABA). There, Sangster's team noted, they feed in different areas, both while raising chicks and in winter.
They even smell different. AviList cites mostly distinct chemical scent profiles for the two, from a 2017 study by Zidat and colleagues, along with their differences in plumage, size, voice and DNA. The third member of the group, the Cape Verde Shearwater, nests only in the Cape Verde Islands and is accidental in North America, says the AOS.
Who decided, and when
- American Ornithological Society (AOS): the 65th Supplement to its Check-list of North American birds
- American Birding Association (ABA): added Scopoli's Shearwater to the ABA Checklist
- eBird and the Clements Checklist: its 2024 taxonomy update
- AviList, the shared world checklist: agrees, with the same names
Is a shearwater a gull?
No. Shearwaters are tubenoses, related to albatrosses and petrels, with tube-shaped nostrils on top of the bill, says the British Trust for Ornithology (BTO); AviList puts gulls with the terns and shorebirds instead. Shearwaters spend their lives at sea, come ashore only to nest and lay a single egg, usually in a burrow.
The name describes their flight: they skim the waves with one wingtip just cutting, or shearing, the water, explains the Agreement on the Conservation of Albatrosses and Petrels (ACAP).
How big are Cory's shearwaters?
About 20 inches (51 centimeters) long, with wings spanning 46 inches (117 centimeters), says Audubon's field guide. It is the largest shearwater in North Carolina's waters, says the Carolina Bird Club. Scopoli's is a little lighter in build.
What are the key differences between Cory's Shearwater and the Great Shearwater?
Look at the head. A Great Shearwater has a sharp black cap, a narrow white band across the back of the neck and the rump, and a blurry dark patch on the belly, says Audubon's field guide. A Cory's looks plainer: brownish gray above and whitish below, the colors smudged together, with a yellow base to the bill and slower wingbeats.
They like different water: Great Shearwaters favor cold water and nest only on a few islands in the far South Atlantic, mainly Gough Island and the Tristan da Cunha group, while Cory's favors warmer water. John James Audubon painted the Great Shearwater as the "Wandering Shearwater," plate 283 of The Birds of America.
Where do shearwater birds live?
At sea. Shearwaters come to land only to nest, in colonies on islands, in burrows up to 3 feet long or in rock crevices. Cory's Shearwaters spend the winter mainly off southern Africa, so most of those seen off North America, at their peak from June to November, are apparently young birds and nonbreeders, says Audubon's field guide. Scopoli's ranges mainly in the tropical eastern Atlantic, says AviList.
Do shearwaters fly at night?
Yes, around their nesting islands. Cory's Shearwaters come and go at their colonies mostly from late afternoon to dawn, and may visit only at night where they are hunted; the parents bring food to the chick at night, and at sea they often feed at night too, says Audubon's field guide.
Their night calls are eerie: in Scotland and Ireland, the cries of nesting Manx Shearwaters led to a widespread belief that trolls were about, says the BTO.
Are shearwaters mutton birds?
Some are. In Tasmania, "muttonbird" means the Short-tailed Shearwater. Its chicks are still harvested each year from late March to the end of April, about 200,000 a year, a practice that is an important part of Tasmanian Aboriginal culture, says Tasmania's Department of Natural Resources and Environment.
The name began on Norfolk Island, where early settlers harvested Providence Petrels for food and an officer called them "the flying sheep." Heavy harvesting and pigs brought to the island wiped them out there.
Where can you see Cory's and Scopoli's Shearwaters?
On a boat trip into the Gulf Stream off North Carolina's Outer Banks, from May into November. Cory's is practically never missed there in the warmer months. Scopoli's is uncommon to at times common: Cory's outnumbers it maybe 3 to 1, but Scopoli's can be the more numerous in late summer, says the Carolina Bird Club. Its highest count is 305, off Hatteras Inlet on August 5, 2023.
From shore, try Cape Hatteras Point in late spring, right after strong easterly winds. Off southern New England, Cory's may be seen from shore more often than other shearwaters, says Audubon's field guide.
Which one did you see?
Look under the wing. Scopoli's shows more white there, reaching out toward the wingtip; on Cory's the outer flight feathers are dark below.
Take photos. The differences are hard to see at sea and best checked on photographs; on a North Carolina boat trip, the Carolina Bird Club says, the more photographers on board the better.
What it does to your list
If you have seen both, and your records say which, your total goes up by one. Birders call a species gained from a split, without a new sighting, an "armchair lifer."
If your old sightings just say “Cory's Shearwater”, they may not say which one you saw. When eBird can't tell which of the new species an old record was, it keeps the sighting as a “one or the other” record. Those stay in your records but don't count as a species.
Other seabirds changed the same year: see the Audubon's Shearwater split and the Brown Booby split, and in 2025 the Fea's Petrel split. And read more about how bird splits and lumps work.
Not sure which shearwater an old record was? Download your eBird data to see every sighting in one file, with its date, its place and your checklist notes.
Check your own list. Drop your eBird download or type your birds: the free checker shows which of them this and other recent changes touched.
Check my list