2024 split

Brown Booby split: the West Coast bird is Cocos Booby

Brown Booby is now two species: the American Ornithological Society (AOS) split it on July 18, 2024, and eBird followed in October 2024. The boobies of the eastern Pacific, including those seen off California and western Mexico, are now the Cocos Booby; the Brown Booby stays the bird of the Atlantic, the Gulf and the Caribbean. If you have seen boobies on both sides of the continent, your list goes up by one.

Updated

A Brown Booby with a dark brown head and back, a white belly and a yellow bill, perched on a branch above the sea
Brown Booby, the Atlantic and Gulf species, painted by John James Audubon. John James Audubon, The Birds of America (1827–38)

What changed

WasBrown Booby Sula leucogaster
NowBrown Booby Sula leucogaster

The Atlantic, the Gulf of Mexico and the Caribbean, including Florida and the Gulf coast. Also the Red Sea and the Indian Ocean, east across the Pacific to Hawaii.

NowCocos Booby Sula brewsteri

The eastern Pacific, from southern California's Channel Islands and western Mexico to islands off Central America and Colombia. The boobies seen off California are this species, and a few now nest in Hawaii.

What are the key differences between a Brown Booby and a Cocos Booby?

The male's head is the big one: an adult male Cocos Booby has white on its head and neck, while adult Brown Boobies, males and females alike, have a uniformly dark brown head and neck. That is from a 2025 study in the journal Western Birds by Eric VanderWerf, who examined 50 museum specimens and photos of 754 living birds from 47 places.

He found at least five differences: head color, the pattern under the wing, the color of the eye, the curve of the bill and the color of the bill. In flight, a Brown Booby usually shows a clean white patch under each wing; a Cocos Booby has more brown in it. Every Cocos Booby has a dark iris that often looks black.

Females are harder. A female Cocos Booby's head is a paler brown, especially on the forehead, but that often shows only up close and in good light. Her bill helps: dark pinkish brown, where a female Brown Booby of the Atlantic has a bright pink one. Young birds can't be told apart at all yet, the study says.

Surprising facts about the Brown and Cocos Boobies

The Cocos Booby is named after a piece of the earth's crust. The Cocos Plate, under the Pacific off Central America, takes its name from Costa Rica's Cocos Island, its only part above sea level, the AOS proposal explains. The name matches the Nazca Booby's, which comes from a plate too. The bird's old name, Brewster's Booby, was ruled out because the AOS is moving away from bird names that honor people.

Painted heads gave the game away. In Mexico, scientists painted the white heads of male Cocos Boobies brown, to look like Brown Boobies, and their own mates treated them aggressively, a 2016 study found, the proposal reports.

The booby trap shares the bird's name. Booby, in both its senses, a foolish person and the seabird, probably comes from the Spanish bobo, according to the New Oxford American Dictionary, as quoted by the Stanford linguist Arnold Zwicky. The booby trap grew out of the first sense.

Audubon thought the name was unfair. Visiting the Dry Tortugas in May 1832, he found the word stupid “utterly inapplicable” to any bird he knew. He wrote that their call sounded “like that of a strangled pig,” and that his pilot had seen fishermen at Veracruz find their way home by following the boobies.

They have moved into California. On November 3, 2017, biologists found four nests and 102 birds on Sutil Island, off Santa Barbara Island in Channel Islands National Park: the first nests in the park. From 1984 to 2014 the species had been seen there only 16 times, the National Park Service says.

One reached Australia. In June 2026 BirdLife Australia reported the country's first Cocos Booby, at Lake Macquarie in New South Wales, nicknamed Coco, and noted suggestions that it may have hitched a ride across the Pacific.

Why it changed

Mostly looks and choice of mate. Where both forms nest on the same Pacific islands, they pair with their own kind: on Moku Mana, off Maui, biologists counted 12 Cocos pairs and 6 Brown pairs in 2021, and no mixed pairs, says the AOS proposal by Eric VanderWerf of Pacific Rim Conservation. Wake Island had 301 Brown pairs and 4 Cocos pairs in 2023, again none mixed.

DNA points the same way. The eastern Pacific population is the most different genetically and split off from all other Brown Boobies about a million years ago, a 2011 study estimated, the proposal notes.

It had been a species before. N. S. Goss described Sula brewsteri in 1888 from San Pedro Mártir Island, in the Gulf of California. It was merged into the Brown Booby in 1944, and the scientist whose work was the basis for that merger never explained why, the proposal says.

Who decided, and when

  • American Ornithological Society (AOS): the 65th Supplement to its Check-list of North American birds, after its committee passed proposal 2024-B-2
  • American Birding Association (ABA): added Cocos Booby to the ABA Checklist
  • eBird and the Clements Checklist: its 2024 taxonomy update
  • AviList, the shared world checklist: agrees, with the same names

What kind of bird is the Cocos Booby?

A large tropical seabird of the booby and gannet family, built like the Brown Booby: 30 to 33 inches long, with a wingspan of almost 5 feet, says Audubon's field guide. Boobies catch fish with spectacular plunge dives from as high as 50 feet, says the National Park Service.

Cocos Boobies nest on islands from southern California south to Gorgona Island, off Colombia, according to AviList, the shared world checklist, and the species is spreading west, north and south, VanderWerf writes, probably as the ocean and its fish change.

How can you tell the difference between a male and female Brown Booby?

Look at the bare skin of the face. In both species the female's facial skin is yellow and she has a dark patch of skin in front of the eye, which the male lacks; the male's facial skin is blue, except in Atlantic Brown Boobies, where it is bright orange-yellow, VanderWerf's study says. In Atlantic birds the bill helps too: usually pink in females and grayish yellow in males.

Females are slightly larger, says Audubon's field guide. And they sound different: males give soft whistles, while females honk or quack, says Animal Diversity Web, the University of Michigan's animal encyclopedia. Audubon himself, in 1835, saw no outward difference between the sexes of adults.

Are Brown Boobies rare?

Not as rare as they were. Brown Boobies are now seen often along the southern Atlantic and Gulf coasts, and north along the California coast, Kenn Kaufman wrote for Audubon in 2024; the California birds are now Cocos Boobies. At the Channel Islands their numbers jumped in 2015, with more than 170 birds at Santa Barbara Island, and the first chick there was confirmed on August 24, 2019, the National Park Service reported.

What are the six species of boobies?

There are now seven in the genus Sula: the Masked, Nazca, Blue-footed, Peruvian, Red-footed and Brown Boobies, the six of older books, and the Cocos Booby, split off in 2024. Add Abbott's Booby of the Indian Ocean, which has a genus of its own, and there are eight boobies, according to AviList. With the three gannets, their family has 11 species.

Why is it called Nazca Booby?

Because it is named after the Nazca Plate, a tectonic plate under the eastern Pacific that holds part of its range, the AOS proposal explains. The Nazca Booby was split from the Masked Booby in 2000 by the American Ornithologists' Union, the AOS's forerunner, on differences in looks and choice of mate. Walter Rothschild had described it in 1902, from Culpepper Island in the Galápagos, says AviList. The Cocos Booby's name was chosen to match it.

Where can you see Cocos and Brown Boobies in the US?

Cocos Boobies: off southern California, especially around the Channel Islands, where they now nest on Sutil Island. Birds from western Mexico sometimes stray inland to the Salton Sea and the Colorado River, says Audubon's field guide.

Brown Boobies: in North America they are seen most often near the Dry Tortugas, Florida, says Audubon's field guide; at Dry Tortugas National Park they perch on the old pilings, says the Florida Birding Trail. Hawaii has both: Brown Boobies nest there, and Cocos Boobies have joined them on islets such as Moku Mana, off Maui.

Which one did you see?

Go by coast first: off California and western Mexico it's Cocos Booby; in the Gulf, the Atlantic and the Caribbean, Brown Booby. In Hawaii both nest, so look closely.

Adult males differ the most. A Cocos Booby male has a whitish head and bluish facial skin; a Brown Booby's head is all dark brown. Females and young birds are harder: see the differences above.

What it does to your list

If you have seen boobies both on the Pacific side and in the Gulf, the Atlantic or the Caribbean, your total goes up by one. Birders call a species gained from a split, without a new sighting, an “armchair lifer.”

If you have only seen them off California or western Mexico, your Brown Booby is now Cocos Booby. If you saw one in Hawaii, it could be either. When eBird can't tell which of the new species an old record was, it keeps the sighting as a “one or the other” record. Those stay in your records but don't count as a species.

The painting at the top is Audubon's plate 207, his Booby Gannet. Another seabird split that year: Cory's Shearwater.

Gained a booby without leaving home? Once your list shows it, here's how to print your updated list.

Check your own list. Drop your eBird download or type your birds: the free checker shows which of them this and other recent changes touched.

Check my list