2023 lump
Pacific-slope and Cordilleran Flycatcher are one again: Western Flycatcher
Pacific-slope Flycatcher and Cordilleran Flycatcher are one species again: the American Ornithological Society (AOS) merged them back into the Western Flycatcher on July 6, 2023, and eBird followed in October 2023. Western Flycatcher is the name the bird had before the split of 1989. If you had counted both, your life list is one species shorter, but every sighting is kept.
Updated
What changed
Nests in shady forests of the West, from southeastern Alaska and the Pacific coast inland to the Rocky Mountains, and south into Mexico. Winters in Mexico.
What is the new name for the Pacific-slope Flycatcher?
Western Flycatcher, Empidonax difficilis. Since July 6, 2023, the AOS counts the Pacific-slope Flycatcher and the Cordilleran Flycatcher as one species again, under the name both had before 1989. eBird made the same change in its October 2023 update, and AviList, the shared world checklist, agrees.
Few birders mourned. “Finally, our long continental nightmare is over!” wrote Michael Retter of the American Birding Association (ABA). The AOS admitted the lump costs North America a species, but said identifying the bird should now be more straightforward.
Surprising facts about the Western Flycatcher
Its scientific name means “difficult.” Difficilis is Latin for difficult, apt for a bird so hard to tell from its look-alike, says the National Park Service.
Its name used to change at state lines. Before the lump, the bird records committees of Idaho and Montana listed only Cordilleran Flycatcher, Washington and British Columbia listed only Pacific-slope, and Alberta simply listed Western Flycatcher. Each went with the form expected around its biggest city, the proposal notes.
It likes bridges and cabins. It often builds its mossy nest under a bridge or under the eaves of a cabin in the woods, says Audubon's field guide, and its nest lining can include feathers and bits of human litter, says the Texas Breeding Bird Atlas.
The Channel Islands have their own version. On Santa Rosa, Santa Cruz and Anacapa, off southern California, the summer flycatchers are larger, with longer bills, paler chests and slightly different voices, says the National Park Service.
Why it changed
The split of 1989 stood on thin ground. It rested mainly on studies by Ned K. Johnson, in 1980 and 1988, of the birds' voices, sizes and proteins, and on signs that the two kept apart where they met in the Siskiyou region of northern California. That evidence of choosy mating came from just four mated pairs, the 2023 proposal points out.
The main meeting ground had been missed. Across a large region of the northern Rockies, from northeastern Washington and northern Idaho to Montana, British Columbia and Alberta, the two forms meet and mix, yet it was blank on the old range maps. There, 28 of 29 recorded songs from eastern Washington and the Idaho panhandle were mixtures, and only 3 of 26 Montana recordings matched the classic Cordilleran call, according to studies cited by the proposal's authors, W. Alexander Hopping and Ethan Linck.
The genes agreed. Pacific-slope birds turned out to be one branch inside the Cordilleran family tree, with mixed ancestry as far east as the Black Hills of South Dakota. The most distinct birds of all live in Mexico's Sierra Madre del Sur, and no one had split those.
The committee voted 9 to 0 for the lump. One member called the overlap zone one massive hybrid swarm, and predicted that Johnson, shown the new data, would have agreed.
Who decided, and when
- American Ornithological Society (AOS): the 64th Supplement to its Check-list of North American birds
- eBird and the Clements Checklist: its 2023 taxonomy update
- AviList, the shared world checklist: agrees
Is the Cordilleran Flycatcher still a species?
No. Since 2023 the Cordilleran Flycatcher is part of the Western Flycatcher, and AviList, too, counts it only as a subspecies, citing the broad region where birds are in between in plumage, voice and DNA.
The proposal suggested six subspecies in all, among them the coastal Pacific-slope birds, a form of the Channel Islands and the interior birds of the US West once called Cordilleran, first described from a bird taken at Boot Spring in Brewster County, Texas.
How do you spot a Western Flycatcher?
Look for a small, greenish flycatcher, 5.5 to 6.7 inches long, with a yellow wash on the throat and a white eye-ring that stretches behind the eye into a teardrop, says Audubon's field guide. From below, its wide bill shows an orange lower half.
Then listen: voice is the most reliable way to tell these look-alike flycatchers apart, says the Texas Breeding Bird Atlas. The song is a rising whee-seet, and the calls a sharp pit-peet or a very high, thin pseeet, Audubon's guide says.
Where do western flycatchers nest?
Low and tucked in, usually near the ground: in a cleft of a streambank, on a stump, among the roots of a fallen tree, under a small bridge or on the rafters of a shed, says Audubon's field guide. On buildings the nest may be more than 10 feet up.
The female builds a cup of moss, grass, rootlets, bark strips, lichens and leaves, lined with plant fibers, hair and feathers. She lays 3 or 4 eggs, which hatch after about 14 to 15 days, and the young fly at 14 to 18 days.
Do flycatchers return to the same nest?
Western Flycatchers sometimes do: a nest site may be used again the next year, or a new nest built in an old nest of a larger bird, says the Texas Breeding Bird Atlas. A pair may raise one or two broods a season.
What do western flycatchers eat?
Mostly insects: small wasps, bees, flies, true bugs, caterpillars, moths and beetles, plus spiders, a few berries and seeds, says Audubon's field guide. It watches from a perch in the shade and darts out to snatch insects in the air, or hovers to pick them off leaves and twigs.
Are flycatchers aggressive?
Toward bigger birds, often. The name of their family, the tyrant flycatchers, reflects how boldly they harass crows, hawks and other large birds, says the National Park Service. In the Pacific Northwest, Western and Hammond's Flycatchers may even defend territories against each other, says Audubon's field guide.
Where can you see a Western Flycatcher?
In summer, in moist, shady woods across the West, often in maples and alders along streams or in canyon groves of oak, sycamore or willow, says Audubon's field guide. In Texas it nests only high in the Guadalupe, Davis and Chisos Mountains, at 6,000 to 8,500 feet, says the Texas Breeding Bird Atlas.
In spring and fall it passes through lowlands across much of the West. Birds that nest along the Pacific coast winter mainly in the lowlands of western and southern Mexico, and interior birds in Mexico's foothills and mountains.
Which bird is it now?
You don't need to choose any more: every Pacific-slope and every Cordilleran Flycatcher is now a Western Flycatcher.
Even experts couldn't reliably tell them apart. Identifying them by sight was considered impossible in the field, and Johnson himself struggled to sort many birds in the hand, the proposal notes. Across the wide area where they meet, birds are in between in looks, song and genes.
What it does to your list
If you had both Pacific-slope and Cordilleran Flycatcher on your list, your total went down by one. Every sighting stays in your records, now as Western Flycatcher.
If you had only one of them, your bird is now Western Flycatcher and your count stays the same. State lists shrank too: “The California state list will drop by one,” a committee member noted.
Another change that year: the Northern Goshawk split. A flycatcher went the other way in 2026: the Tufted Flycatcher split. More on how many bird species the US and Canada have and how bird splits and lumps work.
Saved a Pacific-slope or Cordilleran Flycatcher in Merlin? In eBird it's now Western Flycatcher, and here's how to export your Merlin birds.
Check your own list. Drop your eBird download or type your birds: the free checker shows which of them this and other recent changes touched.
Check my list