2023 split
Western Cattle Egret: the Cattle Egret split explained
The Western Cattle Egret is the Cattle Egret of the Americas, Europe and Africa under a new name: eBird and its Clements Checklist split the Cattle Egret into two species in October 2023, and the American Ornithological Society (AOS) made it official on July 18, 2024, as the Western Cattle-Egret, moving both into Ardea, the genus of the Great Egret. The Eastern Cattle-Egret lives in Asia and Australia. For birders in the US and Canada it's a new name, not a new bird.
Updated
What changed
The Cattle Egret of the Americas (including Hawaii, where it was brought in), Europe and Africa.
Southern and eastern Asia, Australia and New Zealand. In North America only a very rare stray to Alaska's Aleutian Islands.
What are the key differences between a Cattle Egret and a Western Cattle-Egret?
In the US and Canada there are none: the Western Cattle-Egret is the Cattle Egret you know, under its new name. The differences that matter are between the Western and the Eastern Cattle-Egret.
They differ most in breeding plumage. The Western shows less buff-orange on its head and neck, says Birds of the World, while breeding Easterns show extensive rufous, writes Michael Retter of the American Birding Association (ABA). The Western is also smaller and stockier, with a shorter bill, neck and legs: its bare lower leg measures 168 to 180 millimeters, against 205 to 225 in the Eastern, according to a guide to South Asia's birds quoted in the AOS proposal.
The Eastern Cattle-Egret has reached North America only twice that the ABA lists: a bird collected on Agattu Island, in Alaska's Aleutians, on June 16, 1988, and one on Midway Atoll in June and July 1997. The ABA added it to its checklist in November 2024.
Surprising facts about the Western Cattle-Egret
It crossed an ocean by itself. A bird of the Old World, it was first found in northeastern South America in 1877. By 1953 it was nesting in the United States, and within 50 years it was one of the most abundant herons in North America, says the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency.
The Eastern one did the same. Eastern Cattle-Egrets settled Australia on their own by 1948 and New Zealand by 1963, according to AviList.
It waits for airplanes. Cattle egrets have been seen beside airport runways, waiting for planes to blow insects out of the grass, and they fly in from far away to catch insects fleeing a fire, the Tennessee agency says.
Its Arabic name means “father of ticks.” In Egypt it is Abu Qerdan, for the ticks in its nesting colonies. Yet the idea that it picks ticks off cattle is mistaken, says Birds of the World: most of its prey are insects stirred up by the animals.
Hawaii brought it in on purpose. In 1959 the state released 105 cattle egrets to fight insect pests of cattle. By 1982 there were about 13,000, some 120 times as many, and one had turned up on Midway, 2,000 kilometers (about 1,240 miles) from the nearest roost, a 1986 study reported.
Its closest relatives are big herons. The DNA study that moved it to Ardea placed it next to a group that includes the Great Blue Heron, the Gray Heron and Africa's Goliath Heron.
Why it changed
Mostly their breeding colors. The split was first agreed by the Working Group on Avian Checklists, part of an international effort to merge the world's bird lists. Members who voted for it stressed the breeding plumage: not only how much buff the birds show, but the color and texture of their plumes, and the fact that the differences don't fade gradually from one region to the next, the AOS proposal reports.
The evidence was thin. “Somewhat surprisingly,” no genetic study had yet included both forms, the proposal noted. Its author, Terry Chesser, who chairs the AOS committee, had voted against the split in the working group, but recommended following the new world list anyway, as the AOS usually does on an Old World question. AviList, too, says a full genetic review is needed.
The new genus came from DNA. A 2023 study of heron genes placed the Cattle Egret inside Ardea, the genus of the Great Egret and the Great Blue Heron, so the AOS moved it there in the same supplement, a second proposal explains. That's why Bubulcus ibis became Ardea ibis.
The hyphen in Cattle-Egret is on purpose: the AOS's rules call for one when two species are each other's closest relatives. AviList writes the names without it.
Who decided, and when
- eBird and the Clements Checklist: its 2023 taxonomy update
- American Birding Association (ABA): renamed it Western Cattle Egret on the ABA Checklist (and added Eastern Cattle-Egret in November 2024)
- American Ornithological Society (AOS): the 65th Supplement to its Check-list, which also moved both to the genus Ardea
- AviList, the shared world checklist: agrees, writing the names without the hyphen
What is the relationship between cattle and Cattle Egrets?
The egret gets the better deal. Grazing animals flush insects from the grass and the egrets catch them, says Audubon's field guide. In North America that usually means cattle or horses; elsewhere, elephants, camels, zebras and deer. Tractors and even lawnmowers work too.
It pays. Egrets feeding beside cattle need fewer steps and less time to catch their prey, earlier studies found, and more than two-thirds of the egrets on St. Catherines Island, Georgia, fed with cattle, a 1982 study reported. One estimate says they gather 50 percent more food for two-thirds of the energy, the Tennessee agency says.
How rare is a Cattle Egret?
Not rare at all in the South. The Western Cattle-Egret is common all year in Florida, along the Gulf Coast and in parts of the Southwest, says Audubon's field guide, and it has nested in nearly every state, says the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency.
Its numbers have slipped, though. The US Breeding Bird Survey shows it increasing quickly until the early 1990s, then falling at a similar rate, back to near early-1970s levels, according to The State of Canada's Birds.
Where do you find cattle egrets?
In open country: pastures, plowed fields, lawns and roadsides, and also flooded fields and marshes, says Audubon's field guide. It is now found from Alaska to Newfoundland, the Tennessee agency says.
Many winter on the Gulf Coast and in Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean, says the Missouri Department of Conservation. Young birds may wander thousands of miles in random directions, Audubon's field guide notes; that is how most reach Canada, in spring and fall, though the first Canadian nest was found in 1962.
Is the cattle egret invasive?
Not on the mainland, where it arrived on its own; in Hawaii, yes. The US Fish and Wildlife Service calls cattle egrets and barn owls “two invasive migratory bird species in Hawaii” and set up a control order for them there in 2017. Both were brought to the islands in the late 1950s, the egrets to control horn flies on cattle.
Both have been documented preying on endangered Hawaiian stilts, coots, moorhens and ducks. Cattle egrets also gather near airports: in fiscal year 2005, USDA Wildlife Services removed 661 from Hawaii's airports because of the risk of collisions with aircraft. More on the owl in the Barn Owl split.
Do egrets come back to the same place every year?
Many do, though not always to where they hatched. Colonies can last for decades: in 1986 the heronry at Kahuku, on Oahu, was 25 years old, the oldest known in Hawaii. Feeding spots draw them back too: once cattle egrets learn that prey is available somewhere, they return even after the farm machinery has gone, says the US Fish and Wildlife Service.
Young birds roam. Banded nestlings seldom returned to the colony where they hatched, and the young cattle egrets from Alabama headed west around the Gulf of Mexico to Central America, a 1989 summary of band recoveries found.
Where do cattle egrets sleep at night?
Together, in their colonies. The birds return to their colony sites at night to sleep, says the Hawaiʻi Audubon Society, and they nest in trees or shrubs, says Audubon's field guide.
Water matters. In a 1986 survey of Hawaii's roosts, 95 percent were next to water. By day, nesting birds in Alabama fed within about 20 miles of their colony, radio tracking showed.
Which one did you see?
Go by where you saw it. In the Americas, Europe and Africa, it's Western Cattle-Egret.
In the US, look for a small, stocky white heron, 18 to 22 inches long, with a noticeably short yellow bill, says Audubon's field guide. In breeding season its head, breast and back turn buffy orange and its legs and bill reddish, says the Missouri Department of Conservation.
Look-alikes: a Snowy Egret is slimmer, with a black bill and black legs with yellow feet; a Great Egret is much larger, with a longer neck and black legs; and a young Little Blue Heron is white, with greenish legs and a pale bill with a black tip, says the Tennessee agency.
What it does to your list
For birders in the US and Canada it's a new name only: your Cattle Egret is now Western Cattle-Egret.
If you have also seen Cattle Egrets in Asia or Australia, the split adds one to your total. Birders call a species gained from a split, without a new sighting, an “armchair lifer.”
Your list now says Western Cattle-Egret; to see it on paper with all your other birds, pick one of five ways to print your life list.
Check your own list. Drop your eBird download or type your birds: the free checker shows which of them this and other recent changes touched.
Check my list